Analyzing Why Fifty Shades of Grey Actually Worked

November 11, 2015 - Fifty Shades of Grey

Prepare a tomatoes that we will no doubt have thrown during me for this, though after carrying all these months to lay on a film instrumentation of Fifty Shades of Grey we still have to acknowledge that we didn’t hatred it. I’m a initial one to contend that we didn’t like a Fifty Shades book trilogy as a whole. The second one was beguiling adequate and a third was a best, though a initial book was by distant a misfortune in terms of essay and impression development. we could go on and on about how Christian is emotionally and intimately violent to Anastasia, though that isn’t unequivocally applicable to a film given a film downplayed a lot of things that were blatant in a books. we suspicion that they altered and wanting adequate from a book to unequivocally amplify a tract and a characters adequate to make a decent film.

Whether we wanted it or not they did go for a semi-sappy adore story, though it indeed worked in this case. They didn’t totally replace a uneasy past of Christian Grey and they let it play into given he was how he was, though it wasn’t overdone. There was a lot per a book to film interpretation that wasn’t overdone, and in this box that was a best thing that could have happened given of how feeble created a books were. we have held slam from friends and family comparison given we saw Fifty Shades of Grey in theaters and walked out indeed not woeful profitable to see it, though we am prepared to wholly explain how this happened. If we consider about it and give a film another shot, we competence breeze adult fondness it too.

People hated a casting, though did it finish adult working?

One of a biggest complaints from fans, and from a lot of reviewers behind in February, was a apparent miss of chemistry between a film’s lead actors, Dakota Johnson and Jamie Dornan. Personally, we didn’t find them to miss chemistry during all. It’s apparent in some scenes that it contingency have been tighten to a commencement of filming given they were a bit awkward, though as a film went on there was a clarity of chemistry between a actors. It was apparently successful adequate given Universal authorized both sequels though any re-casting.


Chemistry aside, it is loyal to contend Dakota Johnson was a best partial of a film. For this being her initial lead purpose in a underline film, she truly shined in a purpose of Anastasia. we found her opening to be fun, lively, and she unequivocally gave a impression a clarity of self honour that she lacked in a books. In my opinion, she was a misfortune impression of a books given she lets Christian do whatever he wants to her given she doesn’t wish to risk losing him. She doesn’t come opposite as overly genuine like she does in a books and she isn’t fearful to mount adult to him. Firm boundary per a agreement and what she will and will not do are set and Christian respects them all, distinct in a book where he felt she usually indispensable to try things first. The stage where they plead a agreement unequivocally showcases a changes that were finished to Anastasia’s impression given she is wakeful of her possess indulgence and interest and seems to suffer teasing Christian. Kudos to them for holding a stale, descent impression and giving her life.


As for Jamie Dornan, we don’t consider he was a best choice though he no doubt wasn’t a misfortune that could have been. He did a best that he could given a volume of time that he had to prepare. Many people are still dissapoint that Charlie Hunnam didn’t seem as a immature billionaire, though in all integrity we don’t consider he would have been many better. The many vivid thing for me was a subpar American accent. There were times where we cringed conference him contend certain difference given his diction was unequivocally strange. As an American we could simply tell that he struggled by a lot of a dialogue. As distant as how they portrayed Christian, we consider they finished required changes identical to what they did with Anastasia. In a book he is radically a stalker and is unequivocally emotionally, and sexually, violent to his submissives. In a film he comes opposite as a small forward, though seems honestly meddlesome in perplexing to stir Ana. He isn’t prosaic out bold to her like he is in a books and we consider that was a good change.

How was a instruction and script?

Sam Taylor-Johnson had a clever try and after observant how this film was handled, it’s a genuine contrition that she isn’t returning to approach a sequels. we consider losing a component and doing she brought to a film is unequivocally going to harm a destiny films. Her instruction brought a density and magnificence to a story and that’s something a book unsuccessful to do 100%. Along with Taylor-Johnson’s instruction and guidance, a cinematography was gorgeous. we figured if it incited out to be terrible during slightest it was pleasing to demeanour at.


Before removing to a most-anticipated aspect of this movie, let’s cover a writing. It’s no tip that a Fifty Shades trilogy has unequivocally facile and mostly trite writing. Anastasia’s “inner goddess” digression could be left out and never missed and a lot of impression discourse is a bit painful. However, a film somehow prisoner a discourse in a approach that wasn’t overly annoying. They kept certain things from a book that were rather lame, such as “laters, baby” and “fifty shades of fucked up”, though it wasn’t distracting and it didn’t take divided from what was going on. we felt that a characters pronounced adequate though not too many like they do in a books and that was a good thing. If they would have finished a line for line instrumentation it would have been an wholly opposite conversation. It’s one thing to review a discourse that E.L. James wrote in a books, though it’s another to indeed hear it pronounced out loud.

Now… what about a sex scenes?


It was insincere that sex would be a pulling force of a film as it is formed off an amorous trilogy. However, for a story so centralized on a BDSM lifestyle that Christian practices, a film didn’t unequivocally try it in any good detail. we suspicion that Anastasia’s introduction into a “red room” was good finished and she unequivocally played off a whole, “what in a ruin am we doing here” vibe that she has in a book. But, there were usually dual out of 7 sex scenes that took place in a playroom and they were utterly tame compared to what we approaching them to be. It didn’t unequivocally communicate that component of risk and fear that Ana had in a book, nor did it wholly send a stress of a lifestyle to Christian.


On a other hand, a supposed vanilla scenes were unequivocally good done. we suspicion Ana’s decency stage was believable, for what it could be. It gave that clarity of disadvantage and realism that many films don’t constraint when it comes to sex. It also enclosed a clarity of trust between a dual given they seemed to be carrying fun with any other, rather than Ana going along with something given she was intimidated. we appreciated these scenes a lot some-more than a BDSM aspects of a story. Another thing we appreciated about it is a film was unequivocally lacking in a “big O” dialect in comparison to a source material. You could tell that Ana was enjoying herself and finding her possess physique and that we can unequivocally credit Dakota Johnson with. The approach she rubbed her character’s reactions with an open mind and a bit of humor, we could see what she wanted mostly though a lot of dialogue.


With all that said, we consider a categorical thing that we walked divided with per a sex was a volume of nudity. Nudity doesn’t indispensably startle me and we don’t get broke by it, though there was a lot of nudity. Dakota Johnson goes full frontal a good 4 times or some-more and we unequivocally see her physique a most. we could substantially pull a design of her though wanting a anxiety print and from what we review about a production, she didn’t use a physique double, so good for her. One thing that we noticed, and appreciated to a degree, was how she defended some physique hair. we consider it gave some-more of a plausible dimension to a impression and was flattering accurate to many women who leave a certain volume of physique hair. The small sum like that are what finished it some-more beguiling and not as ridiculous. We also get a decent volume of nakedness from Jamie Dornan, though it isn’t full frontal like it is with Johnson. 99% of Dornan’s nakedness is behind nakedness (a.k.a. boundary nudity) and unclothed chest that is flattering customary for masculine actors.

Okay, so a sex wasn’t what it was in a book. What about a ending?

The many softened change, for me, was a ending. In a book it is some-more of a dispute for Anastasia to leave Christian and there are several pages of middle digression from her explaining how unpleasant it was for her to leave. The film shows her indeed wanting to leave and while we see her upset, she seems to know that it’s for her possess good. There is no evidence over a income for her car, there is no evidence about returning a Macbook he gave her, and Christian doesn’t unequivocally put adult many of a fight. He seems to know given she is withdrawal and doesn’t seem as conflicted about it either. It isn’t until she’s in a conveyor that he tries to go after her and she utterly forcefully says no.


The biggest change per a consummate (no joke intended) is when Christian goes into her room after a final punishment. The film shows that Ana does not wish him to hold her and she soon kicks him out of a room. The book chronicle of Ana allows him to come tighten and comfort her and she still wants earthy hit from him notwithstanding a approach she was treated. The film chronicle of Ana is on one side of a bed with Christian on a other. She never looks during him, she does not wish him to hold her, and she kicks him out of a room after he tells her that she can’t adore him. She also leaves a subsequent morning and not a same night. We don’t see her lapse to her unit to cry it out and a film ends as their assembly started: with them observant farewell by shutting conveyor doors.

Exactly how tighten was a film to a source material?


The biggest questions aside from a astringency of a sexuality that flush online were per what is enclosed from a book and what is left out. There was some-more left out than enclosed and during times it did make a film feel a small rushed, though we don’t consider it was a bad thing. Like we pronounced before, if they would have left for a line for line instrumentation it would have run prolonged and gotten flattering ridiculous. we indeed support what was left out of a film given it finished it a lot some-more fun to watch.

What was wanting or changed:

There is reduction sex: The book has a sum of 48 sex scenes. The film has seven.


Anastasia does not get a job: In a book, Ana interviews for jobs and is hired right out of college as an partner to a editor during a edition organisation in Seattle. The film has no discuss of her even requesting or interviewing for jobs.

Mrs. Jones is non-existent: As we know if we read, Christian’s housekeeper was utterly prevalent in a books and she did have some stress in Fifty Shades Freed. However, she is not enclosed or even mentioned in a movie.

Christian’s strenuous jealousy with other group in Anastasia’s life: The book shows Christian as constantly overprotective of Ana and sceptical of a other group in her life such as Jose Rodriguez, Ethan Kavanagh, and Paul Clayton. The film doesn’t etch this over Christian display adult during a bar and pulling Jose divided from Ana when he tries to make a pass during her.


Ethan Kavanagh is non-existent: Speaking of jealousy and self-existent characters, Kate’s hermit Ethan does not make an coming in a film and is not mentioned. He is another impression that becomes rather critical to a plot, so we assume he will seem in a second film.

Dr. Greene is non-existent: Beyond a discerning discuss by Christian seeking how a GYN appointment went, we did not see or hear anymore about Dr. Greene. She is in all 3 books, so this competence be another casting proclamation they are saving until a sequels.

Anastasia’s outing to Georgia: There were several chapters dedicated to Ana’s outing to revisit her mom in Georgia. The outing also had events such as her being silently upgraded to initial class, her being some-more concerned with her mom and stepfather, Christian dropping in on her, some-more sex, arguing with Christian about profitable during an IHOP, even some-more sex, and a atmosphere glider. The film fundamentally depicts Ana carrying lunch with her family, being forsaken in on by Christian during a hotel, and being taken drifting in a glider. That’s it.


Issues with Anastasia’s eating habits were minimal: Christian fundamentally shoves food down Ana’s throat via a book trilogy and consistently tells her she needs to eat. She also describes that she is so intimidated by Christian that she finds it formidable to eat around him. In a movie, he presents her food and a underlying tinge of eating being critical to him is there, though it’s not overbearing. She doesn’t seem to have an ardour problem during all in a movie.

There is 0 discuss of Leila: As we know from a book trilogy, an spooky ex-submissive of Christian’s comes into play rather dangerously and is initial introduced towards a finish of a initial book. Leila does not exist in a movie, so she’s nonetheless another thing being saved for a sequels.

More argumentative sex scenes were wanting entirely: Scenes involving verbal sex, tampon removal, and sex by danger that were prevalent in a book were not benefaction in a film during all. If you’ve left this prolonged though watching, don’t let a internet dope we given they simply aren’t in a film.

The record is upgraded: The book introduced us to Ana as if she was attending college in a late 1980s. She didn’t have a personal mechanism and seemed to be totally mislaid when it came to technology. The book also employed Apple and Blackberry products. The chronicle of Ana we get in a film has an comparison though decent flip-phone and a computer, though a mechanism is broken. Christian still gifts her a Macbook, though he does not give her a dungeon phone. Blackberry was also transposed with a iPhone.

Kate is not as protecting of Anastasia: Kate is a lot some-more concerned in a book than in a movie. She gets rather melancholy towards Christian and when he upsets Ana she scarcely kicks him out of their unit in an try to keep him divided from her friend. The film depicts Kate as roughly non-existent. She is there, though she isn’t unequivocally concerned in Ana’s life and seems to be a some-more giveaway spirited, standard college girl.

Anastasia is a feisty, humorous girl: Let’s be honest, Ana was most a articulate square of card in a book. The film portrayed her in a unequivocally opposite light and it was a required change. She has an apparent and endearing clarity of amusement and has self respect. She isn’t overly assertive towards Christian, though she knows what she wants and isn’t bashful about perplexing to speak about it. That is not something Ana does in a book during all.


Final thoughts?

There is some-more that we could go on about per Fifty Shades of Grey, though altogether we did suffer a film a lot some-more than a book. we consider if this was a gait they are environment for a destiny cinema they are off to a decent start. we approaching it to be terrible and was agreeably surprised. Although we won’t have Sam Taylor-Johnson returning to direct, there are things to demeanour brazen to per a subsequent dual movies.

As we pronounced during a commencement of this article, a initial was a misfortune of a 3 books. Fifty Shades Darker an Fifty Shades Freed are still by no means masterpieces, though in comparison to Fifty Shades of Grey they are a lot some-more enjoyable. The tract picks up, characters turn some-more involved, and a story isn’t usually about Christian and Ana carrying sex. It unequivocally good could be usually given we knew a source element adequate to compare, though judging from how sufferable this initial instrumentation incited out to be we am some-more than open to observant how a subsequent dual cinema play out.

More shades ...

› tags: Fifty Shades of Grey /